ASTM A516 Grade 60, also commonly written as A516GR.60, A516 Gr.60, A516 GR 60 and ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415], is the inch-pound Grade 60 designation in ASTM A516/A516M. Grade 415 is the SI designation in the same specification, not a converted Grade 60 value. ASME SA516 Grade 60 (SA-516 or SA-516M Grade 60 or Grade 415) is the corresponding ASME family designation, not merely another spelling of the ASTM name. An ASTM-only certificate does not automatically satisfy a specified SA-516 order, and the reverse is also true. The official product page is ASTM A516 Grade 60.

This page compares ASTM A516 Grade 60 with ASTM A515 Grade 60. The two grades share a “60” number and the same public-Scope tensile range, but they are not the same specification. A515 Grade 60 is carbon-silicon plate for intermediate- and higher-temperature service; A516 Grade 60 is carbon-manganese plate for moderate and lower-temperature service where notch toughness is important. A515 figures below are the official public-reference values already disclosed on ASTM A515 Grade 60. The comparison is not a substitution approval.

Lower-Temperature versus Intermediate- and Higher-Temperature Vessel Plate

Topic ASTM A516 Grade 60 ASTM A515 Grade 60
Intended service, public Scope Moderate and lower-temperature pressure-vessel service where improved notch toughness is important, with ASME SA516 Grade 60 as the corresponding ASME designation Intermediate- and higher-temperature service in welded boilers and other pressure vessels, from the A515/A515M-17(2022) public Scope
Steelmaking / grain practice Killed carbon-manganese plate; A516 is the fine-grain vessel-plate family contrasted on the official A515 page Killed carbon-silicon steel made to a coarse austenitic grain-size practice, as described on the official A515 Grade 60 page
Usual delivery condition, public compilations Normalized over 1.50 in. [40 mm] unless otherwise ordered; as-rolled at or below unless otherwise agreed or unless notch toughness is specified MetalMate’s Grade 60 compilation citing 17(2022), as used on the official page: normalizing over 50 mm [2 in.], with plate at or below that thickness normally as-rolled unless otherwise ordered. That is a compilation reference, not a public-Scope official clause
Thickness in the public Scope Official Grade 60 chemistry bands run through over 8 in. [200 mm]; that is a composition schedule, not a stock list The 17(2022) public Scope gives no numerical maximum thickness; the limit is the capacity of the composition to meet the required mechanical properties

Chemical Composition

Element / condition ASTM A516 Grade 60 [Grade 415], public reference ASTM A515 Grade 60, public reference
Carbon, max (heat = product) 0.21 / 0.23 / 0.25 / 0.27 / 0.27 at 1/2 in. and under / over 1/2 to 2 / over 2 to 4 / over 4 to 8 / over 8 in. 0.24 / 0.27 / 0.29 / 0.31 / 0.31 at 1 in. and under / over 1–2 / over 2–4 / over 4–8 / over 8 in.
Manganese Grade 60 thickness- and option-dependent ranges, including a thin-plate choice (see the official A516 page) 0.90% heat / 0.98% product, with a conditional manganese allowance as stated on the official A515 page
Silicon 0.15–0.40% heat, 0.13–0.45% product 0.15–0.40% heat, 0.13–0.45% product
Phosphorus / sulfur, max 0.025 or 0.035 each; see the official A516-page source note 0.025% public-source maximum as used on the official A515 page

Mechanical Properties

Property ASTM A516 Grade 60 [Grade 415] ASTM A515 Grade 60
Tensile strength 60–80 ksi / 415–550 MPa, ASTM A516/A516M-25 public Scope 60–80 ksi [415–550 MPa], A515/A515M-17(2022) official public Scope. Matching ranges are not identity of the specifications
Minimum yield strength 32 ksi, SSAB Grade 60 required properties as used on the official A516 pages. Not published here as 220 MPa or as an official SI specification value 32 ksi [220 MPa], public reference used on the official A515 page, not an official Table 2 extract
Minimum elongation 25% in 2 in. [50 mm] and 21% in 8 in. [200 mm], with A20/A20M or SA-20 adjustments 25% in 2 in. and 21% in 8 in., official public reference, with applicable A20 adjustments

A matching grade number and a matching tensile range do not make A515 Grade 60 an A516 Grade 60 substitute. The service-temperature basis, grain practice, carbon bands and usual normalizing thickness differ. ASTM A516 Grade 65 and ASTM A516 Grade 70 are different A516 strength grades; they are not A515 Grade 60. Substitutions require design and project approval.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Are ASTM A515 Grade 60 and ASTM A516 Grade 60 the same steel?

No. They share a grade number and the same public-Scope tensile range, but A515 Grade 60 is written for intermediate- and higher-temperature service with a coarse-grain practice, while ASTM A516 Grade 60 is written for moderate and lower-temperature service as a fine-grain vessel plate.

Can ASTM A515 Grade 60 replace ASTM A516 Grade 60 because the tensile range is 60–80 ksi on both?

No. A matching tensile range is not substitution approval. Review the vessel design temperature, toughness requirements and the named specification before considering any alternative.

Is the normalizing thickness the same for ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A515 Grade 60?

Not in the compilations used on the official pages. Grade 60 A516 is commonly compiled as normalized over 1.50 in. [40 mm]; A515 Grade 60 as normalized over 50 mm [2 in.], unless otherwise ordered. Agree the actual condition on the purchase order.

Where are the official product pages for ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A515 Grade 60?

Start with ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A515 Grade 60. Use ASME SA516 Grade 60 when the A516 order is written to the ASME designation.

For plate to ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415] or ASME SA-516 Grade 60, please contact Gangsteel with the designation, edition, unit system, delivery condition, dimensions, quantity and any supplementary requirements. Learn more about our pressure-vessel and boiler steel plate at Gangsteel.

A516 Grade 60 vs A515 Grade 60: Lower-Temperature vs Higher-Temperature Vessel Plate