ASTM A516 Grade 60, also commonly written as A516GR.60, A516 Gr.60, A516 GR 60 and ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415], is the inch-pound Grade 60 designation in ASTM A516/A516M. Grade 415 is the SI designation in the same specification, not a converted Grade 60 value. ASME SA516 Grade 60 (SA-516 or SA-516M Grade 60 or Grade 415) is the corresponding ASME family designation, not merely another spelling of the ASTM name. An ASTM-only certificate does not automatically satisfy a specified SA-516 order, and the reverse is also true. The official product page is ASTM A516 Grade 60.

This page compares ASTM A516 Grade 60 with ASTM A105/A105M carbon steel forgings for piping components (flanges, fittings, valves and similar parts). A105 is not a pressure-vessel plate specification. The A105 figures below are from ASTM A105/A105M-24, Tables 1 and 2. Gangsteel does not have an official A105 product page, so A105 is listed without a link. The comparison is not a substitution approval.

Plate Specification versus Forging Specification

Topic ASTM A516 Grade 60 ASTM A105 / A105M-24
Type of specification ASTM A516/A516M pressure-vessel carbon-manganese plate, with ASME SA516 Grade 60 as the corresponding ASME designation Carbon steel forging specification for piping components, for ambient- and higher-temperature service in pressure systems. Maximum forging mass 10 000 lb [4540 kg] in this specification
Product form in view on this page Plate for welded vessels, boilers and related equipment when the project names this grade Forged piping components. An A105 forging certificate is not a plate certificate, and tubesheets or hollow cylindrical forgings for vessel shells are outside A105’s stated scope
Official Gangsteel product page ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASME SA516 Grade 60 No official Gangsteel A105 product page; values below are from A105/A105M-24, not from a Gangsteel product page

The two designations may appear together on the same equipment — for example plate shells with A105 flanges — but that is a bill-of-materials choice, not evidence that the materials are equivalent. Each line item keeps its own specification, edition, product form and certificate.

Chemical Composition

Grade 60 chemistry is the official public-reference table already disclosed on ASTM A516 Grade 60. A105 chemistry is the heat-analysis limits in A105/A105M-24, Table 1. Earlier A105 editions used a lower manganese-adjustment ceiling; use the ordered edition.

Element / condition ASTM A516 Grade 60 [Grade 415], public reference ASTM A105/A105M-24, Table 1
Carbon, max Thickness-banded 0.21 / 0.23 / 0.25 / 0.27 (heat = product in the official table) 0.35%
Manganese Thickness- and option-dependent Grade 60 ranges (see the official page) 0.60–1.05%; for each 0.01% carbon below 0.35%, manganese may increase 0.06% above 1.05%, up to 1.65% in the 2024 edition
Phosphorus, max 0.025 or 0.035; see the official-page source note 0.035%
Sulfur, max 0.025 or 0.035; see the official-page source note 0.040%
Silicon 0.15–0.40% heat, 0.13–0.45% product 0.10–0.35%
Copper / nickel, max Not a single named limit on the official Grade 60 chemistry table 0.40% each; Cu + Ni + Cr + Mo + V shall not exceed 1.00%
Chromium / molybdenum / vanadium, max Not a single named limit on the official Grade 60 chemistry table 0.30% Cr, 0.12% Mo, 0.08% V; Cr + Mo shall not exceed 0.32%

Mechanical Properties

Grade 60 strength figures are the public-reference values already disclosed on the official Grade 60 pages. A105 mechanical figures are A105/A105M-24, Table 2. The two product forms are tested to different specimen rules and are not interchangeable on that account alone.

Property ASTM A516 Grade 60 [Grade 415] ASTM A105/A105M-24, Table 2
Tensile strength 60–80 ksi (Grade 60) and 415–550 MPa (Grade 415), ASTM A516/A516M-25 public Scope. The two unit systems are independent 70 ksi [485 MPa] minimum
Minimum yield strength 32 ksi, SSAB Grade 60 published required properties as used on the official pages. 32 ksi is not published here as 220 MPa or as an official SI specification value 36 ksi [250 MPa] minimum, 0.2% offset or 0.5% extension-under-load
Minimum elongation 25% in 2 in. [50 mm] and 21% in 8 in. [200 mm], with A20/A20M or corresponding SA-20 thickness adjustments 22% on a standard round 4D specimen; 30% on strip specimens 5/16 in. [7.94 mm] and over (a thickness formula applies to thinner strip)
Reduction of area, min Not a listed official Grade 60 acceptance value on the pages used here 30%, for round specimens only
Hardness Not specified as an A516 Grade 60 acceptance value on the official pages used here 197 HBW maximum (Table 2). Small forgings accepted on hardness only are held between 137 and 197 HBW under the 8.3.4 rule in the 2024 edition

An ASME plate order for this family is written as SA-516 Grade 60 or SA-516M Grade 415. The corresponding forging designation, when it is required, is a separate SA-105 (or other) requirement. ASTM A516 Grade 65 and ASTM A516 Grade 70 are different specified A516 strength grades, not A105 equivalents and not an unchanged Grade 60 order.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can ASTM A105 replace ASTM A516 Grade 60 plate?

No. ASTM A105 is a forging specification for piping components, not a pressure-vessel plate grade. This comparison does not treat ASTM A105 as a plate substitute for ASTM A516 Grade 60.

If a vessel uses ASTM A516 Grade 60 plate and A105 flanges, are the materials the same?

No. Each item keeps its own specification and certificate. Using both materials on one piece of equipment is not evidence that ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A105 are equivalent.

Which edition of ASTM A105 is tabulated beside ASTM A516 Grade 60 on this page?

ASTM A105/A105M-24, Tables 1 and 2. Earlier editions used a 1.35% manganese-adjustment ceiling rather than 1.65%. Use the edition named on the A105 order.

Where is the official product page after reading this ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A105 comparison?

Start with ASTM A516 Grade 60 for the plate grade. Use ASME SA516 Grade 60 when the plate order is written to the ASME designation.

For plate to ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415] or ASME SA-516 Grade 60, please contact Gangsteel with the designation, edition, unit system, delivery condition, dimensions, quantity and any supplementary requirements. Learn more about our pressure-vessel and boiler steel plate at Gangsteel.

A516 Grade 60 vs A105: Pressure-Vessel Plate vs Carbon Steel Forgings