ASTM A516 Grade 60, also commonly written as A516GR.60, A516 Gr.60, A516 GR 60 and ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415], is the inch-pound Grade 60 designation in ASTM A516/A516M. Grade 415 is the SI designation in the same specification, not a converted Grade 60 value. ASME SA516 Grade 60 (SA-516 or SA-516M Grade 60 or Grade 415) is the corresponding ASME family designation, not merely another spelling of the ASTM name. An ASTM-only certificate does not automatically satisfy a specified SA-516 order, and the reverse is also true. The official product page is ASTM A516 Grade 60.

This page compares ASTM A283 Grade C with ASTM A516 Grade 60. Both are carbon steels, but they are written to different specifications and are not automatic substitutes. A283 Grade C is structural-quality carbon plate for general application. A516 Grade 60 is carbon-manganese plate for welded pressure vessels in moderate and lower-temperature service where notch toughness matters.

Why ASTM A283 Grade C and ASTM A516 Grade 60 Are Different

Topic ASTM A283 Grade C ASTM A516 Grade 60
Intended use in the specification Structural-quality carbon plate for general application; not an automatic pressure-vessel acceptance route Pressure-vessel carbon-manganese plate for moderate and lower-temperature service where notch toughness matters
General requirements basis A6/A6M structural-plate basis, as stated on the official A283 Grade C page A20/A20M (or the corresponding SA-20 provisions on an ASME order)
Current grade set in the public Scope used here A283/A283M-24 public Scope names Grades C and D A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415] is one strength grade in the A516 family

A familiar carbon-steel description is not evidence of identity. A change from one designation to the other needs the applicable design and material review, then a revised purchase designation, edition and certificate.

Published Strength References

The figures below are the public-reference values already disclosed on the official product pages. They are not certified extracts of a named current ASTM or ASME edition. Accept material against the designation, edition and unit system named on the order.

Property ASTM A516 Grade 60 [Grade 415] ASTM A283 Grade C
Tensile strength 60–80 ksi (Grade 60) and 415–550 MPa (Grade 415), from ASTM A516/A516M-25 public Scope. The two unit systems are independent 55–75 ksi [380–515 MPa companion], from the SSAB Grade C mill reference with Ferrobend / American Alloy Steel cross-check; not an official mechanical-table extract. The SI companions are conventional published pairings
Minimum yield strength 32 ksi, SSAB Grade 60 published required properties as used on the official Grade 60 pages. 32 ksi is not published here as 220 MPa or as an official SI specification value 30 ksi [205 MPa companion], same SSAB / compilation basis as the official A283 Grade C page
Minimum elongation 25% in 2 in. [50 mm] and 21% in 8 in. [200 mm], with A20/A20M or corresponding SA-20 thickness adjustments 25% in 2 in. [50 mm] and 22% in 8 in. [200 mm], with gauge applicability and any A6 width adjustment

Chemistry Is Specified Differently

Grade 60 carbon maxima are thickness-banded (0.21% in the thinnest listed band, rising to 0.27%) and, in the official public-reference table, are the same for heat and product analysis. Manganese for Grade 60 cannot be summarized by one range: plates ½ in. [12.5 mm] and under have a lower range and a permitted higher alternative. Do not carry the ASTM A516 Grade 65 or ASTM A516 Grade 70 manganese presentation into a Grade 60 purchase, and do not carry the Grade 60 options into an A283 Grade C purchase.

The official ASTM A283 Grade C public-reference chemistry is different in form as well as in value. Carbon is given as a 0.24% heat-analysis maximum; a separate product-carbon limit is not established by that reference, and the blank product-carbon cell is not zero or an implied equality. Manganese is given as 0.90% heat and 0.98% product maxima from the American Alloy Steel compilation used on that page. Phosphorus and sulfur, silicon thickness bands and the conditional 0.20% copper minimum (only when copper steel is specified) have the compilation basis stated on the official A283 Grade C page. Those references are not a complete official current-edition table.

Substitution Requires Project Approval

This comparison does not approve substituting ASTM A283 Grade C for ASTM A516 Grade 60, or the reverse. Strength level, chemistry presentation, general-requirements basis and intended service differ. Related A516 grades such as ASTM A516 Grade 65 and ASTM A516 Grade 70 are likewise different specified strength grades, not an unchanged order.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can ASTM A283 Grade C replace ASTM A516 Grade 60?

Not without the project’s design and material approval. ASTM A283 Grade C is a structural-quality specification. ASTM A516 Grade 60 is a pressure-vessel grade. The comparison is not a substitution approval.

Are ASTM A283 Grade C and ASTM A516 Grade 60 the same because both are carbon steel?

No. The specifications, general-requirements basis, chemistry presentation and published strength references differ. A carbon-steel label is not evidence of identity.

Are the strength figures for ASTM A283 Grade C and ASTM A516 Grade 60 official edition extracts?

No. They are the public-reference figures already disclosed on the official product pages, with the source notes given in the tables. The edition named on the purchase order governs acceptance of each material.

Where are the official product pages for ASTM A283 Grade C and ASTM A516 Grade 60?

Start with ASTM A516 Grade 60 for the pressure-vessel grade, and ASTM A283 Grade C for the structural grade. Use ASME SA516 Grade 60 when the order is written to the ASME designation.

For plate to ASTM A516/A516M Grade 60 [Grade 415] or ASME SA-516 Grade 60, please contact Gangsteel with the designation, edition, unit system, delivery condition, dimensions, quantity and any supplementary requirements. Learn more about our pressure-vessel and boiler steel plate at Gangsteel.

A283 Grade C vs A516 Grade 60: Structural Plate vs Pressure-Vessel Steel