ASTM A516 Grade 65, also commonly written as A516GR.65, A516 Gr.65, A516 GR 65 and ASTM A516/A516M Grade 65 [Grade 450], is the inch-pound Grade 65 designation in ASTM A516/A516M. Grade 450 is the SI designation in the same specification, not a converted Grade 65 value. ASME SA516 Grade 65 (SA-516 or SA-516M Grade 65 or Grade 450) is the corresponding ASME family designation, not merely another spelling of the ASTM name. An ASTM-only certificate does not automatically satisfy a specified SA-516 order, and the reverse is also true. The official product page is ASTM A516 Grade 65.
This page compares ASTM A516 Grade 65 with CSA G40.21 44W (300W). 44W is a weldable structural-quality steel, not a pressure-vessel plate grade. Gangsteel does not have an official 44W product page, so the 44W figures below are taken from CSA G40.21-13 Table 3 and published abridged mechanical tables, and are listed without a link. The comparison is not a substitution approval.
Pressure-Vessel Plate versus CSA Structural Steel
| Topic | ASTM A516 Grade 65 | CSA G40.21 44W (300W) |
|---|---|---|
| Type of specification | ASTM A516/A516M pressure-vessel carbon-manganese plate, with ASME SA516 Grade 65 as the corresponding ASME designation | CSA G40.20/G40.21 structural quality steel, Type W (weldable). 44W is the inch-pound grade name; 300W is the SI name for the same yield class |
| Typical intended use | Welded pressure vessels in moderate and lower-temperature service where notch toughness matters | General construction, engineering and fabrication. Charpy testing is not part of the standard 44W (Type W) test schedule; a 44WT / 300WT grade and impact category must be ordered if notch toughness is required |
Chemical Composition
| Element / condition | ASTM A516 Grade 65 [Grade 450], public reference | CSA G40.21-13 44W / 300W, Table 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon, max | 0.24 / 0.26 / 0.28 / 0.29 / 0.29 at ½ in. and under / over ½ to 2 / over 2 to 4 / over 4 to 8 / over 8 in. (heat = product) | 0.22% max; 0.23% max for thickness over 100 mm (4 in), footnote (f) |
| Manganese | 0.85–1.20% heat, 0.79–1.30% product, both Grade 65 thickness bands | 0.50–1.50% |
| Phosphorus, max | 0.025 or 0.035; see the official-page source note | 0.04% |
| Sulfur, max | 0.025 or 0.035; see the official-page source note | 0.05% |
| Silicon | 0.15–0.40% heat, 0.13–0.45% product | 0.40% max; 0.15–0.40% required for Type W over 40 mm (1½ in) unless the steel is aluminium-killed to Table 3 note (b) |
| Grain-refining elements, max | Not a single named limit on the official Grade 65 chemistry table | 0.15% max in Table 3 (aluminium used for grain refining is treated separately in the notes) |
Mechanical Properties
| Property | ASTM A516 Grade 65 [Grade 450] | CSA G40.21 44W / 300W |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | 65–85 ksi / 450–585 MPa, ASTM A516/A516M-25 public Scope | 65–90 ksi (450–620 MPa) in abridged CSA mechanical tables, for the listed product forms. Some mill tables (SSAB, Leeco) publish 64–90 ksi; that mill range is disclosed here and is not substituted for the abridged CSA table |
| Minimum yield strength | 35 ksi, SSAB Grade 65 required properties as used on the official pages. 35 ksi is not published here as 240 MPa or as an official SI specification value | 44 ksi (300 MPa) up to 2½ in. (about 65 mm); 40 ksi (275 MPa) above 2½ in. to 4 in. in the abridged table |
| Minimum elongation | 23% in 2 in. [50 mm] and 19% in 8 in. [200 mm], with A20/A20M or SA-20 adjustments | 20% min, longitudinal in 8 in., in the abridged CSA table (elongation adjustments in G40.20 apply) |
An overlapping tensile range is not identity of the specifications. ASTM A516 Grade 60 and ASTM A516 Grade 70 are different A516 strength grades, not 44W equivalents. Substitutions require design and project approval.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can CSA 44W replace ASTM A516 Grade 65?
Not without the project’s design and material approval. 44W is a CSA structural grade. ASTM A516 Grade 65 is a pressure-vessel plate grade. This comparison is not a substitution approval.
Is 44W stronger than ASTM A516 Grade 65 because its yield is 44 ksi?
The abridged 44W yield is 44 ksi up to 2½ in., against a 35 ksi Grade 65 minimum on the official pages. Tensile ranges overlap but are not the same, and the specifications and intended use still differ.
Does standard 44W include a Charpy test like some ASTM A516 Grade 65 orders?
No. Standard Type W 44W does not include a Charpy test. A 44WT / 300WT grade and impact category must be ordered if notch toughness is required. Grade 65 impact tests are also ordered only when required.
Where is the official product page after reading this ASTM A516 Grade 65 and 44W comparison?
Start with ASTM A516 Grade 65. Use ASME SA516 Grade 65 when the order is written to the ASME designation.
For plate to ASTM A516/A516M Grade 65 [Grade 450] or ASME SA-516 Grade 65, please contact Gangsteel with the designation, edition, unit system, delivery condition, dimensions, quantity and any supplementary requirements. Learn more about our pressure-vessel and boiler steel plate at Gangsteel.
